Spiritual Whack-A-Mole: Why Fixing Behavior Doesn’t Fix You

Spiritual Whack-A-Mole: Why Fixing Behavior Doesn’t Fix You

Do you remember Chuck E. Cheese? If you do, you’re dating yourself a little. Remember Whack a Mole? Doesn’t get any more “old school” than that.

There’s a reason “behavior modification” feels like spiritual whack-a-mole.

You knock down one habit… another bad habit pops up.You tighten discipline… stress hits… and suddenly you’re right back where you started.

Most of the time, it’s not because you’re lazy.It’s not because you “don’t love God enough.”It’s because behavior change and heart change are not the same thing.

And confusing the two keeps people exhausted.

Behavior can change quickly. Add pressure. Add accountability. Add consequences. Most people can adjust their behavior under the right conditions. That’s why diets work for three weeks. That’s why people can be “on their best behavior” when someone is watching.

External pressure produces temporary compliance.

But heart change? That’s slower. Deeper. Harder to fake.

You can change a habit without ever touching the belief underneath it. And that’s the part that actually drives the behavior.

Let’s take people-pleasing. (I did my doctoral dissertation on this one)

You can decide, “I’m going to stop saying yes to everything.”You can even practice saying no.

But if deep down you still believe:

·       “My value comes from being needed.”

·       “If I disappoint people, I’ll be rejected.”

·       “Other people’s opinions matter more than mine.”

…then your behavior will snap back the moment stress rises.

Why? Because belief always wins every time!

The brain is loyal to what it believes about your Identity. It will defend that belief, even if the belief is wrong.

This is why Scripture relentlessly targets the heart.

“Guard your heart, for everything you do flows from it.” (Proverbs 4:23)

Notice the direction. Behavior flows from the heart. Not the other way around.

Jesus wasn’t primarily a behavior manager. He was a heart surgeon. In the Sermon on the Mount, He didn’t just say, “Don’t murder.” He said, “Let’s talk about anger.” He didn’t just say, “Don’t commit adultery.” He said, “Let’s talk about lust.” He went underneath the action to the belief.

Because “The root produces the fruit.”

You can staple good fruit onto a sick tree, but eventually gravity wins.

This is where identity enters the conversation.

If you don’t believe you have value, you will overfunction in relationships.If you don’t believe you’re secure, you will grasp for control.If you don’t believe you’re loved, you will perform.

You cannot sustain behavior change until the belief about who you are changes.

That’s why Romans 12:2 doesn’t say, “Try harder.”It says, “Be transformed by the renewing of your mind.”

Transformation… real transformation, happens when the mind changes what it believes to be true.

Let’s stay with the people-pleasing example.

Behavior-level change says:“I need to stop saying yes.”

Heart-level change says:“I already have value. My opinion matters. God’s approval is secure. I don’t have to earn love.”

When that belief shifts, saying no no longer feels like a threat to survival. It becomes alignment.

That’s the difference.

Behavior change is often fear-driven.Heart change is truth-driven.

Behavior change without identity change is fleeting.Heart change produces durable obedience.

And here’s where this gets beautifully practical.

If you only work on habits, you’ll constantly fight relapse.If you work on belief, habits begin to shift from the inside out.

This is why willpower eventually fails. Willpower is a muscle. It gets tired. Stress depletes it. Exhaustion drains it. Trauma triggers it.

Belief, however, shapes perception. And perception shapes response.

When you see yourself differently, you respond differently.

You don’t fight for worth… you act from worth.You don’t perform for acceptance… you live from acceptance.You don’t obey out of fear… you align out of security.

God focuses on the heart because the heart drives everything.

When identity shifts from “I am only as good as my usefulness” to “I am deeply loved and secure in Christ,” behavior follows almost naturally.

Not perfectly. Not instantly. But steadily.

Transformation isn’t about acting differently.

It’s about seeing yourself differently.Believing differently.Agreeing with what God says about you.

And when belief changes, behavior doesn’t have to be forced.

It flows.

The question isn’t, “What behavior do I need to fix?”

The deeper question is, “What do I currently believe about myself that makes this behavior feel necessary?”

Start there.

Because when the heart changes, the life follows.

Struggling with anxious thoughts? Check out my course "Finding Peace in the Chaos." A 6-week video course to help you overcome anxiety and find peace.